If you’ve ever traded pets in Roblox Pet Simulator 170 and walked away feeling like you got the short end of the stick, you’re not alone. Knowing what your pet is actually worth and what someone else’s is worth can make or break your collection. Fair trades keep the community healthy and help you grow your roster without getting scammed or lowballed.

What does “fair trade value” even mean here?

It’s not about what a pet costs in-game coins or gems. Fair trade value is what other players are willing to give up for that pet based on rarity, demand, and how hard it is to get. Some pets look flashy but are common. Others look plain but are nearly impossible to find and those often hold more trading power.

Where do people even check pet values?

Most experienced traders use updated community lists or value guides. These aren’t official Roblox doesn’t set pet prices but they reflect real trades happening right now. You can find rankings sorted by rarity and trade power, like in our breakdown of the rarest pets and their current standing. Keep in mind: values shift as new updates drop or events end.

How do I figure out if my offer is fair?

Start by comparing pets at the same tier. Don’t just eyeball it check recent trades in Discord servers, Reddit threads, or in-game trade logs. If you’re offering a Golden Huge Tiger for a Rainbow Enchanted Cat, ask yourself: have you seen that trade happen recently? If not, one side is probably overpaying.

A common mistake? Assuming shiny = valuable. A glittery pet might be cool to show off, but if everyone has it, its trade weight is light. Meanwhile, an older event pet with no sparkle might be quietly sitting at the top of value charts.

What should I avoid when trading?

  • Trading without checking multiple sources first
  • Accepting “I’ll throw in five commons to balance it” quantity rarely equals quality
  • Letting FOMO push you into bad deals during limited-time events
  • Ignoring market shifts after game updates (a pet’s value can tank overnight)

Any tips for spotting undervalued pets?

Look for pets that are rare but under-the-radar. Sometimes newer players don’t realize how hard a pet was to get, or how few exist. We’ve put together a list of pets flying under the radar that savvy traders are quietly collecting. These can be goldmines if you grab them before the crowd catches on.

Is there a tool or site I can trust?

No single tool is perfect, but cross-referencing a couple of active Discord communities and fan-run value trackers helps. One external resource some traders use is PS99 Value it’s not official, but it’s frequently updated by players who track live trades. Always double-check with real people, though. Bots and outdated lists lie.

What’s the fastest way to learn this stuff?

Watch trades happen. Lurk in busy trading hubs. Ask questions (politely). See what offers people accept and which ones they laugh at. Experience beats theory every time. And if you’re unsure, hold onto the pet. Better to wait than regret.

Still unsure where to start? Revisit our full walkthrough on how to assess pet trade value step by step. It breaks down real examples and red flags you’ll actually encounter in-game.

Quick checklist before hitting “Trade”:

  • Check at least two value sources don’t rely on memory or one Discord server
  • Compare rarity tiers, not looks shininess doesn’t equal scarcity
  • Ask for recent proof “I saw this trade yesterday” beats “I think this is fair”
  • Walk away if pressured good trades don’t expire in 10 seconds
  • Keep a log track what you’ve traded and for what. Patterns will emerge